OPINION

The Day I Truly Failed

May 16, 2007
Zainub Razvi

Choosing a career is one of life's more important decisions. Very often, for a variety of reasons, in my part of the world, this is not a decision one has absolute freedom to make. Quality education in Pakistan, especially if you intend to attend a private institution, is not always something a middle class family with multiple children can afford easily. Conversely, any field that has the impression of being well paid or otherwise (regardless of whether or not this impression is correct) always influences the decision making process. But economic viability is rarely the biggest reason why many young people in Pakistan are forced to abandon their dreams.

This disaffiliation is often fueled by something that appears on the face much less simpler, but is in fact much more sinister. I'm talking about an inherent culture of undermining the whole thought process of dreaming. Almost from early childhood, family and friends will try, sometimes compulsorily, to tone down and re-shaped your aspirations. Young, innocent minds are relentlessly fed with misplaced ideologies that deem some professions noble and others dishonorable, as if even talking about them was a cardinal sin.

Doctors are the saviors of the world in this philosophy, yet if your child suggests that she or he would like to be a nurse they ought to have dropped their mind somewhere (even when ironically nurses are professionals belonging to the same field of medicine). Engineers, MBAs and Computer Science graduates are intelligent, gifted people, who earn five figure salaries, but lawyers, writers, journalists, beauticians, fashion designers, chefs, and a whole array of other so-called unconventional fields, no sir, these professions are only respectable so long as your child doesn't want to be in them, especially if your child happens to be a girl.

Even the well educated in Pakistan depict such prejudiced reservations about certain fields and who can enter them. If somehow you happen to be one of those people who has resisted this metamorphosis of your mindset in your early childhood, an ideological struggle against these misplaced social norms awaits you for the rest of your life. Your own interests, skills and aptitude, your development needs and way of thinking, all this counts for little in front of these social norms. Any reliable career counseling service outside of Pakistan would tell you the importance of self-assessment and motivation. Not in Pakistan.

Because career counseling at school and college level is a non-existent phenomenon, the only advice you receive is from your ever-so-considerate and mammoth circle of family and friends. Not only will they offer their services without you asking for them, they will also be mighty offended if you don't take their recommendations. It is the not the love and concern of our elders that aspiring youth like me are questioning. Contrary to what our elders may think, we value this love and concern they show for us, and we even respect the lessons their experience of life has taught them.

But I have struggled to understand why we must confine our self to the lessons they have learned, why we cannot have the freedom to learn from our own life's experiences as we live it? And why our respect of our elders must be called into question if we dare do dare to disagree with the lessons they have learned? Must rebellion be always frowned upon?

The youth of this country wants to grow and prosper, I want to grow and prosper too, I have dreams, I want to follow them, and see what my dreams hold for me. Our elders, my elders, also want me to grow and prosper, but they also have dreams of their own for us. It stays calm if our dreams aren't conflicting with theirs, but if they do differ, why must we, the portrayers of these dreams, be the ones to abandon our possibilities? My elders have raised me up encouraging me to think - if that hadn't been the case I'd not have been writing this today - yet whenever that ability to think, which they have instilled in me with their upbringing, enables me to think differently, there is either an uncomfortable silence between us, or a rowdy disagreement. I struggle every day to comprehend why this should be so.

Today I am struggling again. The results of my first professional B.D.S. examinations come out today. It is neither with pride, not with any regret, that I tell you that I failed these exams. I don't know yet how many papers I failed to clear, but I am a reluctant dentistry student, the exams meant little to me, so it doesn't matter either way. Yet still, there is a tinge of regret I feel every time I am informed of a result from this dentistry programme I am subjecting my self to. It is not the failure in an exam, test or assessment that disheartens me, but the continued failure to disassociate myself from the very social norms I hate so much. I don't say dentistry isn't a noble profession, but it just isn't for me.

Every subsequent dentistry exam from that day nearly two years ago when I enrolled in this dentistry program giving up my dreams of studying journalism, is another grave, painful reminder of that fateful day. That day when I succumbed to family and social pressure, that day when I gave up on my dreams, that was the day I truly failed. And today? Today is merely another anniversary of that epic failure. But what is this article in itself? A purposeless admission of failure, another obituary of my dreams or merely another sigh of regret, even I don't know for sure. But either way, there is a lingering hope that if not myself, someone somewhere else can draw something from this chronology of my failure(s) and not make the same mistake(s) that I did. May all our dreams come true.

One's only rival is one's own potentialities. One's only failure is failing to live up to one's own possibilities. In this sense, every man can be a king, and must therefore be treated like a king."-Abraham Maslow

Zainub is an opinionated dreamer, intermittent blogger, massive sports fan and aspiring journalist recently liberated from studying boring dentistry. She blogs at Kaleidoscope, freelances for Spider and Sci-Tech World both part of the Dawn media group, and also writes at ezines Desicritics and Chowk. She is currently majoring in General History and minoring in International Relations and Mass Media Communications/Journalism at the University of Karachi.
eXTReMe Tracker
Keep reading for comments on this article and add some feedback of your own!

Comments! Feedback! Speak and be heard!

Comment on this article or leave feedback for the author

#1
Deepti Lamba
URL
May 16, 2007
11:23 AM

Beautiful post Zainub. Don't be disheartened- failure is when you refuse to strive again and I am sure the lioness in you will never admit defeat:)

#2
Aaman
URL
May 16, 2007
11:30 AM

Very compelling, and will strike a chord with many readers. I'm fortunate enough to have drifted into something I enjoy, and also have time available for other wonderful things - like family, movies, books, and Desicritics - I'm sure you'll end up with much the same fine balance as the years go by.

#3
Amrita
URL
May 16, 2007
11:42 AM

Hey Z - my version of dentistry school was business school. I put in three years and was good at it: i just didn't care for it. My decision to shift schools and streams cost me an extra year of school but it was worth it.

What I'm trying to say is, it really is never too late. You can be a dentist and a journalist, you don't have to end up in a doctor's office if you don't want. I hate to be a Pollyanna but honestly, I'll never think of those years in business school as wasted years because I learnt a lot from them and I'm sure you can twist things around too.

Best of luck!

#4
Akash
May 18, 2007
07:34 AM

How can a talented articulate writer like you give up on your dreams. I cant believe it...
Break free. NOW.

#5
smallsquirrel
May 18, 2007
09:05 AM

There could be a million ways you can fix this situation. It is never too late to make a change. You could pass dentistry school and use that as an "in" to join a travelling team of health professionals, where you could also be a correspondent! You could bunk dental school altogether and tell your parents that clearly it's not working out.

Look, I am the first in my family not to go into medicine. What did I do? I got a masters in sociolinguistics. My family was livid for years but they got over it. Find a way to make it work.

I have found that having a well thought out plan helps your arguments. Get into journalism school. See a career counselor if you can find one. Then present your parents with the whole picture. Parents are afraid of the nebulous, but if you can show that you have thought this out and are not being whimsical, you have a much better shot at them agreeing.

best of luck!

#6
Tanay
URL
May 18, 2007
11:07 PM

Zainub, first of all, the world doesn't come to an end incase you were not able to clear the test. I can get what you feel meaning more than your personal failure in the test it's what the world and in the social circle you stay would say is what bothers you.

The scene is not very different in India. I am an engineer from one of the top schools in India and graduated from my school close to 4 years back. I had even qualified for the IIT, if you know that this is one of the best schools in India but I didn't wish to join as my rank was in the fag end. Then after my engineering, when I dubbed my offers from US schools to do my Masters, I know many people said I was a fool. I really know how it feels when there is a contradiction between what you value and what you like and the way world in you live thinks. It's hard, and you need a hard skin to live over it.

Now I am trying for something else in my career along with my work and also teach on weekends in slum schools. These are things that I like. So I am pretty sure that you will one day become a journalist a raring and an appreciated one. Don't bother about the results, take it easy and I am sure you would tide over this hard time soon.

I read when I am down, else keep to myself. Try and do what you like the best to be back to your spirits again. Zainub is the not the best, she is the bestest. Cheer up.

#7
prat
May 23, 2007
04:50 AM

irrational optimism is what is needed.
i just started work 10 months ago at a s/w co.
far from my dream.
but there are so many ppl who have suffered to get what they want. like charles dickens. at as young an age as 12 he had to go thru so much. you've to forget all the fry suffering u go thru.
maybe everyday you need to work few hours towards your dream. it'll give u hope to continue with what u are presently doing.
there's no free lunch .. there's also no feast everyday..

#8
prat
May 23, 2007
04:51 AM

irrational optimism is what is needed.
i just started work 10 months ago at a s/w co.
far from my dream.
but there are so many ppl who have suffered to get what they want. like charles dickens. at as young an age as 12 he had to go thru so much. you've to forget all the fry suffering u go thru.
maybe everyday you need to work few hours towards your dream. it'll give u hope to continue with what u are presently doing.
there's no free lunch .. there's also no feast everyday..

#9
prat
May 23, 2007
04:56 AM

irrational optimism is what is needed.
i just started work 10 months ago at a s/w co.
far from my dream.
but there are so many ppl who have suffered to get what they want. like charles dickens. at as young an age as 12 he had to go thru so much. you've to forget all the fry suffering u go thru.
maybe everyday you need to work few hours towards your dream. it'll give u hope to continue with what u are presently doing.
there's no free lunch .. there's also no feast everyday..

Add your comment

(Or ping: http://desicritics.org/tb/5333)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.






Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!