OPINION

Bollywood: Creating A Mythical Desi Hero

May 18, 2006
DesiGirl

Some of my most favourite songs in Indian movies are those from the Tamil movie 'Alaipayuthey' (Saathiya was a very diluted effort in Hindi, IMHO). A R Rahman's music was fabulous, as always, as he elevated even the wedding mantras that are oft-repeated by the purohits in a bored monotone, to the heights of cooldom with his 'Mangalyam' number.

But today, as I was listening to it while washing the dishes, I couldn't help but wonder about the whys and wherefores of the lyrics. The 'hero' character sings about his beloved in such poetical and glowing terms that it is guaranteed to make the knees of any desi girl go weak. It is either 'endless smiles forever, I was born a hundred times just for this day' or the 'love kabaddi' (a la 'Shikdum'!) where the girl is to taunt and tease him with her various antics. There is also this evergreen song where he compares every single colour in the spectrum to his lady love.

All this is great, just dandy. What I do not understand is, what is the inspiration for all this? These big-time declarations of 'luurve' that are nowhere to be found in our society. All these men who woo their dilbaras, whatever happens to them once the objective has been reached? Boys who supposedly chased the girls till she gave in seem to give up on them once the mangalsutra is on her neck. I have never seen a husband voluntarily hold his wife's hands, especially in front of family. In fact, the norm is pretty much to pretend that you don't really know each other all that well. Why? Ma won't be happy.

My friend recently forwarded a 'joke' to me about the difference in a romance at various points in life - 6 weeks, 6 months, 6 years. The change, of course, is quite dramatic, from 'Hi honey' of 6 weeks to 'hey you!' of 6 years!! What a shame!

Last night, I watched this Telugu blockbuster 'Nuvvostanante Nennodantana', starring RDB's Karan Singhania, Siddharth, in the main role. The things he does to win the girl's hand is unbelievable. This boy, a rich NRI kid from London, chucks everything away and settles down in his sweetheart's village, where he suffers untold agonies in the form of eating really, horribly spicy food (he is afterall, an NRI yaar, go easy on him!), cleans the cow sheds, milks the cow and gets doused with its wee while he's at it - and the list continues. As I saw his try to catch a good night's sleep on the hard ground, my heart bled for this young man who so carelessly gave up his Down-stuffed Silent Night mattress.
Okay, okay I know movies and reality can and should never be clubbed together even in the same sentence. But the moviemakers cannot be extrapolating things to such a degree that the result is a 180 degreeulta of real life, can they? Not to a nation where the men folk aren't exactly pampering their wives silly by getting them flowers everyday and romancing the be-jesus out of them?

So why are our lyricists and movie makers still feeding the poor girls of today such overwhelmingly beautiful scenarios wherein the man of their dreams will woo them to the ends of the world? Aren't they setting everyone up for a rather steep fall?

Or is it just my cynical self coming to the fore?

PS: Can I just say this isn't an attack on the desi men around the world so please do not slag me off too much. I just would like to understand the fundamentals of the masala we are fed on a daily basis, that's all!


Writing is my passion and music is my soulmate. When I have a book in my hand and my music blasting in my ears, I am on top of the world. I would love to be a published author someday. But till then, I shall enthrall you all with my creative genius. :)
eXTReMe Tracker
Keep reading for comments on this article and add some feedback of your own!

Comments! Feedback! Speak and be heard!

Comment on this article or leave feedback for the author

#1
Rohan Venkat
URL
May 18, 2006
02:56 PM

Hm. Better start working those rhymes.

Bollywood is one vast escapist paradise. That answer the question?

#2
Rebel
May 19, 2006
03:56 AM

Classic paradox. If a man gets romantic, a woman would feel elated to show 'nakhraa' as if it will prolong something (I can't use that word here). And when men are busy with their own work following the die-hard tradition that only applies to men to protect and provide for women, these same women would whine saying, "Why does all men change after marriage?" Thats because unlike womens, man's responsibilities increases manifold after marriage. And well, to admit that a woman can't understand a man is pretty much like drinking the 'neem' soup or a 'Kaarela' soup.

P.S: I read your postscript after I wrote this comment.

#3
Righta
URL
May 24, 2006
04:10 AM

Art is great when it has no connection with reality, when it yearns for larger than life 'targets'. Men don't hold their wives hands in front of his family since from childhood, 'touching' the opposite sex(even his own mom- after some specified limits!) is not approved- isn't that(conditioning) a simple fact of life in India?. Isn't the Indian greeting of the 'folded hands' symbolic of India Non-Touching ideals!.

Do you think lyrics which portray real life with details of dish-washing and snarling traffic evoke feelings of great relaxation and appreciation?. Art is what you can;t have in real life, its escape from reality, its expression of pent up emotions, its the strength which you never had balls to discover, its that girl which you never found, its the boy who never was.

Add your comment

(Or ping: http://desicritics.org/tb/1819)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.






Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!